Mediterranean Economies 2023
DOI: 10.1401/9788815411167/c6
Except for Malta (recording an
increasing trend over time) and Spain (witnessing a decreasing trend over time), all
countries recorded first an increasing trend (from 2017 to 2020) and then a decreasing
trend (from 2020 to 2022) in terms of ad hoc investments in ICT employee training. This
evidence suggests that the COVID-19 pandemic outbreak drove firms in almost all EuroMed
countries to provide their employees with more technological support and training to
enhance their ICT knowled
¶{p. 200}ge and their digital capabilities so
that they could cope with the abrupt shift toward remote working. However, as office-based
or hybrid work is restored, there are likely to be fewer incentives (or resources) for
firms to train their staff.
¶
¶
As for numbers, Malta is confirmed
top of the rankings (28.2). By contrast, France and Cyprus have shown the sharpest
decrease in the period 2020-2022, while Greece comes last also for this indicator.
Surprisingly, among the most industrialised countries, French companies, followed by their
Italian counterparts, were those that undertook the lowest number of training activities
in digital technologies. Values recorded over time from Spain are also worthy of note:
ever-diminishing ICT training investments contrast with the country’s overall level of
digitalization and its good overall DESI performance, which was outperformed only by Malta
(see fig. 1). As for the average position of EuroMed countries in comparison to that of EU
countries, the Med country average is substantially aligned with the European mean. The
box plot shows, however, that the pandemic has not contributed to convergence among the
countries analysed. Rather, lack of homogeneity in their values has increased over time
and was particularly marked in the shift from 2020 to 2022.
4.2.2. The DESI sub-dimension of «Connectivity»
As regards connectivity, continuous
and sustained growth can be noted in the period considered for all EuroMed countries. Once
again, it is Spain (69.7) which experiences the most sustained growth, followed by France
(64.2) and, quite surprisingly, Italy (61.2). The most significant increase is recorded by
Cyprus which rose from 23.9 to 58.8 in the period 2020-2022. Instead, Portugal recorded the
lowest growth (26.1 to 51.6 in the period 2017-2022). Italy, occupying third place, stands
out as being very well positioned in terms of digital infrastructures while it is far behind
in the formation of human capital (see figure 2). At the bottom of the ranking, we find
Greece (49.6) followed by Croatia (48.1). It should be noted that the growth of connectivity
among the Med countries is substantially in line with that recorded for the average of EU
countries. Only in the starting year, 2017, were the analysed countries, on average,
slightly behind the EU mean. ¶{p. 203}The box plot shows that the pandemic
has contributed to reduce the gap among EuroMed countries in their level of connectivity,
such that convergence has actually been maintained.
¶
Figures 7, 8 and 9 allow a
finer-grained analysis of this dimension, breaking it down into some basic indicators,
namely: «the overall fixed broadband take-up» (related to the sub-dimension «fixed broadband
take-up») and «the mobile broadband take-up» and «5G coverage» (both related to the
sub-dimension «mobile broadband»).
With regard to the consumption
behaviour of households, subscriptions for fixed broadband connections have been growing
rapidly over the years. All countries, except Slovenia, have seen an increase over time in
the number of families who have subscribed to take advantage of a higher bandwidth. Some
countries, notably Cyprus, Greece and Portugal, have witnessed a more marked increase over
time. In 2022, Cyprus ranked first (91.8 per cent), followed by Malta (88 per cent) while
Italy came last (65.7 per cent). Among the most industrialised EuroMed countries, Spain
(82.9 per cent) and France (79.5 per cent) are at the top of the ranking. The EuroMed mean
is substantially in line with the European mean and the variability, as shown by the
boxplot, among the different countries does not appear to decrease over the years, with the
exception of Italy which, in the last year surveyed (2022), is particularly distant from the
rest of the Med and EU countries, being an outlier.
Looking at figure 8, it can be
immediately noted that, in comparison to subscriptions for fixed broadband connections,
those related to mobile broadband connections are a little higher for all countries and that
all countries recorded a more marked increase over time. In particular, Spain improved its
position, with almost 94 per cent of the Spanish population having a subscription to a
mobile broadband data service, followed by Cyprus (90.7 per cent) and France (87.6 per
cent). Also for this indicator, Italy lies bottom, with only 65.7 per cent of people
subscribing to a mobile broadband connection. Interestingly, Greece shows a very different
performance in comparison to fixed BB take-up (fig. 7) as it moved from fourth in the
EuroMed ranking to bottom in the case of Mobile BB take-up (fig. 8).
The rate of increase recorded over
the years is quite similar and regular for the various countries under examination.
Varia
¶{p. 205}bility is not particularly marked between countries, a sign
that in this sector a similar trend in the behaviour of the population prevails. That said,
the mean of the Med countries is slightly lower than the European average for all three
years considered.