Mediterranean Economies 2023
DOI: 10.1401/9788815411167/c5
Moreover, food security at the
country (macro) level does not automatically imply food security at the household
(micro) level. Access to food by households across countries with different income
levels is largely determined by physical and socio-economic conditions, and while
countries can be food secure, households may not [FAO 2015; Barlow et
al. 2020]. For smallholder farmers,
¶{p. 146}for
example, focusing on cash crops limits the allocation of the available land to the
production of subsistence vegetables and key staple foods, increasing their
dependency on local market conditions [Hashmiu, Agbenyega and Dawoe 2022]. Access to
food may also be challenging for households that lose from trade liberalization,
such as smallholders along the food value chain who were previously protected and
-unable to withstand the competition- see their incomes decline after trade
liberalization; or households whose incomes are generated in non-competitive
sectors; or those whose incomes are too volatile to bear local and global food price
fluctuations. Drawing on a global analysis of microdata spanning 132 countries in
the 2014-2017, Barlow et al. [2020] found that, in low-income
countries, poorer households were more likely to be food insecure despite liberal
trade policies. Persistent structural challenges, including labour market rigidities
and poor infrastructure (among others) tend to undermine the effects of
liberalization. Moreover, the increased availability of- and access to food may not
always be positive from a utilization point of view. Thus, food security at the
macro-level does not necessarily ensure the quality and nutritious content of food,
but, to the contrary, may lead to unhealthy changes in diets and insufficient intake
of micronutrients because of the affordability of alternative unhealthy food
options.
Therefore, food-related trade
policies should be accompanied by a coherent set of domestic policies that ensure
equal access to food and adequate nutrition in disadvantaged regions and households,
such as reducing food import tariffs, income transfer, and/or targeted food
subsidies. Long term policy solutions are also required to tackle structural issues
affecting food security. These are different from short term policy responses that
are designed to address short-run food spikes [Kerr 2012].
In countries where rural
poverty is widespread, engaging smallholders in international trade and facilitating
their access to global markets is crucial. At the country level, empowering
smallholder farmers by improving their access to information, to inputs, and to
finance is necessary to increase their productivity. Clustering in farm associations
and cooperatives has also increased smallholder farmers’ participation in global
markets [Matthews 2014]. International cooperation in agriculture can also improve
food security in several ways. For example, Official
¶{p. 147}Development Assistance through Aid-for-Trade targeting
agriculture has proven efficient in improving productive capacities in the
agricultural sector. International organizations often carry out micro-level
interventions to make agricultural value chains more inclusive, for example by fund
training programs for farmers or developing special initiatives to empower women
working in agriculture
[4]
. An increasing number of multinationals is also using the fair-trade
certification system to shorten the value chain and work directly with smallholder
farmers, which helps them capture a larger share of the price and increase their
income. At the supranational level, however, the global framework governing
international trade in agriculture must provide more attention to food security and
inclusive trade. With increasing standards, a decreasing share of smallholders are
engaged in global trade [Maertens and Swinnen 2014], whereas multinational firms –
being more capable of overcoming these barriers – increasingly dominate agricultural
production and trade.
2. Food security in the MENA region: what is at stake?
Since the 1970, the MENA region is
a net importer of food including essential grains and meat. On average, while food
imports decreased from 19.4 per cent in 1975 of merchandise imports to 11.3 per cent in
2021, its exports significantly decreased from 7.3 per cent to 3.6 per cent over the
same period, making this region a net importer. This makes it one of the most exposed
and potentially volatile regions to developments in the global food markets.
Since the region has limited
potential to increase its food production due to limited water resources and arable
lands, its food security will increasingly depend on imports. Figure 1 depicts the food
security outlook at the global level. The map shows that MENA countries are among those
countries with a moderate risk and stable conditions from a food security perspective.
Except for Egypt and Libya, the rest of the MENA region
¶{p. 148}(including Morocco, Tunisia, Algeria, Jordan, Palestine to,
Syria, and Lebanon) witness significant rainfall or vegetation deficit. The food
security outlook for Syria and Yemen, both suffering from over a decade of internal
political (armed) conflict, is classified as highly risky.
¶
Figure 2 compares food security
indicators across MENA countries. Overall, recent FAO estimates suggest that around 32
per cent of the region’s citizens lack access to sufficient and nutritious food
[Keulertz and Byiringiro 2022]. While political and/or armed conflicts have severe
repercussions on the high prevalence of food insecurity (40 per cent or higher) in
Djibouti and Libya, and economic sanctions are likely to take a heavy toll on food
security in Iran, high prevalence of moderate and severe food insecurity is also found
in relatively politically stable countries, such as Jordan. In the latter, conflicts in
neighboring countries and the resulting influx of refugees from Syria added to the
pre-existing pressure on food supply. At the same time, Jordan has little potential for
agricultural expansion due to limited water availability. In fact, water availability in
Jordan is among the lowest in the world, partly due to the transboundary water
challenges that involve Israel, Syria, and Lebanon around the Hasbani River and Lake
Tiberias [Christoforidou et al. 2022]. Egypt is also likely to face
water challenges due to the construction of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam and in
the absence of significant enhancements in sustainable water supply and agricultural
expansion (ibid). The prevalence of moderate to severe food insecurity affects nearly
one third of the population in Morocco, Tunisia, and Lebanon. The Maghreb region has
been witnessing drought and above-average weather temperatures [Mandour 2021], leading
to decreasing vegetation. As oil-poor countries, their export revenues are also unlikely
to secure sustainable food imports. As for Lebanon, the economy has been suffering from
longstanding challenges related to political instability, chronic internal and external
deficits, high import dependence, and the concentration of Palestinian and Syrian
refugees in the Eastern and Southern parts of the country. Recent shocks including the
pandemic and the Beirut Port explosion pushed the country towards a financial and
economic collapse, leading to skyrocketing food prices and endangering the livelihood of
an increasing proportion of the population.¶{p. 150}
Figure 3 depicts the share of trade
in food in total merchandise trade in selected MENA economies. On the exports side,
Morocco has the highest share of food exports in total merchandise exports (23.1 per
cent), followed by Palestine (21.2 per cent), Lebanon (19.6 per cent), and Egypt (18.1
per cent). Despite the high prevalence of food insecurity in these countries, the share
of food exports in total merchandise exports is higher than the same average in low-and
middle-income countries (10.4 per cent), and the share of the MENA region altogether
(3.8 per cent). These exports are mainly exports of fruits and vegetables [Keulertz and
Byiringiro 2022]. In contrast to these south Mediterranean economies, higher income
countries in the region such as Israel, Saudi Arabia, and other Gulf countries have
negligible shares of total merchandise exports that are concentrated in food exports.
¶{p. 151}
Note
[4] The International Trade Centre, for example, has launched the «SheTrades Initiative» to improve women’s livelihood in export-oriented value chains. For more details, see https://intracen.org/media/file/11681.