Mediterranean Economies 2023
DOI: 10.1401/9788815411167/c7
For every country,
each dimension is evaluated by utilising a set of questions
assessed on a 5-point scale. The measurements of the LPI related
to 160 countries are calculated biennially by the World Bank,
giving the opportunity to compare countries over time. For this
reason, the LPI is extensively employed by scholars to conduct
benchmarking studies in international logistics [Bugarcic,
Skvarciany and Stanisic 2020; Karaduman et
al. 2020; Su and Ke 2017; Wang and Choi
2018]. In table 1 the 2018
¶{p. 240}LPI ranking
is reported for both EU and non-EU Mediterranean countries for
the purpose of comparison.
EU Mediterranean
Country |
LPI
rank |
Non-EU
Mediterranean Country |
LPI
rank |
France |
16 |
Israel |
37 |
Spain |
17 |
Turkey |
47 |
Italy |
19 |
Egypt |
67 |
Portugal |
23 |
Bosnia-Herzegovina |
72 |
Slovenia |
35 |
Montenegro |
77 |
Greece |
42 |
Lebanon |
79 |
Cyprus
|
45 |
Jordan |
84 |
Croatia |
49 |
Tunisia |
105 |
Malta |
69 |
Morocco |
109 |
Algeria |
117 |
||
Syria |
138 |
||
Libya |
154 |
||
Palestine |
– |
||
Source:
our calculation based on data from the World Bank
database (https://lpi.worldbank.org). |
The data show the
difference between the competitive position of Mediterranean
countries belonging to the EU and those countries that are not
EU member states. Excluding Israel and Turkey (whose ranking is
comparable to the most advanced EU countries), the rest of the
countries show a lower level of competitiveness of their
national transport and logistics systems with reference to North
African (e.g., Tunisia, Morocco, Algeria and Libya) and Middle
East countries (e.g., Lebanon, Jordan and Syria). These data
demonstrate the logistical difficulties on the part of many
Mediterranean countries before the outbreak of the war between
Ukraine and Russia.
Beyond the above
difficulties, the freight transport and logistics sector in
Mediterranean countries is beset by the following challenges:
– Fragmentation of
transport infrastructure: the lack of a coordinated approach to
transport infrastructure development and maintenance across
Mediterranean countries has resulted in fragmentation of
transport infrastructure. This has led to inefficiencies in
freight transportation and logistics processes, increased
logistics costs and reduced competitiveness. Improvements in
infrastructure, such as roads, railways, and ports, are needed
to support the growth of the sector.
– Complexity of
supply chains and logistics processes: Mediterranean countries
have complex supply chains due to their geographical location,
which makes them prone to natural disasters, geopolitical risk
and conflicts. This results in long lead times, increased
inventory levels and higher logistics costs.
– Insufficient
investments in infrastructure and technology: Mediterranean
countries are facing funding constraints due to economic and
political instability, resulting in insufficient investments in
transport infrastructure and technology. This has hindered the
development of efficient transport networks and logistics
processes.
– Lack of
standardization and harmonization of regulations: the lack of
standardization and harmonization of regulations across
Mediterranean countries has resulted in administrative barriers
to cross-border freight transportation and logistics, leading to
increased transportation costs and delays.
¶{p. 241}
– Sustainability:
the freight transport and logistics sector is a significant
contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution and other
externalities. Mediterranean countries need to adopt sustainable
practices, such as the use of alternative fuels, to reduce their
environmental impact.
– Trade
facilitation: cross-border trade can be hindered by
administrative barriers, such as customs procedures and
regulations. Mediterranean countries need to harmonize their
regulations and improve trade facilitation measures to reduce
the time and cost of cross-border trade.
– Competitiveness:
Mediterranean countries face competition from other regions,
such as Asia and Northern Europe, which have more advanced
logistics infrastructure and services. Mediterranean countries
need to improve their competitiveness by investing in logistics
infrastructure, adopting innovative technologies, and improving
the efficiency of logistics processes.
Faced with the
above-mentioned challenges, some Mediterranean countries have
implemented logistics projects to improve their freight
transport and logistics sectors. Examples of measures adopted by
some Mediterranean countries are described below [ISPI 2023b].
Morocco has
implemented a national logistics strategy that focuses on
improving logistics infrastructure, regulations and services.
The strategy aims to make Morocco a logistics hub for Africa and
improve the country’s competitiveness. It has resulted in the
development of new logistics platforms, such as the Tanger Med
port, which is now one of the largest ports in the Mediterranean
region. The strategy has also led to improvements in logistics
regulations, reducing administrative barriers to cross-border
trade and improving the efficiency of customs procedures.
As a result of
these efforts, Morocco has seen an increase in foreign direct
investment in the logistics sector and a growth in exports.
Greece has also
implemented a national logistics strategy that aims to improve
logistics services and reduce logistics costs. The strategy
focuses on developing new logistics infrastructure, improving
the efficiency of existing infrastructure, and harmonizing
regulations across different modes of transport. As a result of
these efforts, Greece has seen improvements in its logistics
performance, with the country’s rank in the LPI climbing from
52nd in 2014 to 42nd in 2018.¶{p. 242}
Egypt has launched
a national logistics centre that aims to improve logistics
infrastructure and services, particularly in the area of
transport and storage. The centre provides a platform for
coordination between different stakeholders in the logistics
sector, including government agencies, logistics service
providers and industry associations. It also provides support
for logistics companies looking to invest in Egypt, including
providing information on regulations, incentives and investment
opportunities.
Turkey has invested
heavily in logistics infrastructure to become a logistics hub
for Eurasia. The country has developed a network of logistics
centres and logistics villages, which provide integrated
logistics services to companies. Turkey has also implemented a
number of initiatives to improve the efficiency of its logistics
processes, including the development of an electronic customs
clearance system and the adoption of a single-window system for
trade. As a result of these efforts, Turkey has become a major
logistics hub for the region, connecting Europe and Asia.
In Spain, one of
the most important countries in the Mediterranean, the freight
and logistics industry is growing steadily. The country has an
extensive network of highways, railways and ports, making it one
of the major freight transport hubs in the Mediterranean. In
addition, the country is increasingly investing in
temperature-controlled logistics to support the export of fresh
produce such as fruit and vegetables.
In Italy, which is
located in the heart of the Mediterranean, the freight and
logistics industry is also growing. The country has major
commercial ports such as Gioia Tauro, Genoa and Naples, which
are important transit points for goods travelling between
Europe, Asia and Africa. In addition, Italy is investing in the
digitalization of logistics, with the goal of improving the
efficiency and transparency of freight transport through
technology.
Tunisia is becoming
increasingly important as a transportation hub for the region.
The country has major commercial ports such as Rades, which is
capable of handling large cargo ships. In addition, Tunisia is
investing in modernizing its transportation infrastructure and
promoting logistics as a strategic sector for the country’s
economic development.
Lebanon, located in
the eastern part of the Mediterranean, is a major transportation
hub for the Middle East region. The country has major commercial
ports such as the port of Beirut, ¶{p. 243}which
is a transit point for goods travelling between Europe, Asia and
Africa. However, the country’s recent economic and political
crisis has had a significant impact on the freight and logistics
industry.
The above examples
demonstrate the importance of a coordinated approach to
logistics development, involving different stakeholders from
government and industry. They also highlight the need for
investments in transport infrastructure and the adoption of
innovative technologies to improve logistics processes. The next
section discusses the impact of the war between Russia and
Ukraine on the logistics and transport sector in the
Mediterranean region.
2. The effects of the Russia-Ukraine war on logistics in the Mediterranean region
The war in Ukraine
is having a severe impact on freight transport and trade.
Ukraine’s transport networks suffer on-going destruction, which
is causing serious disruption in global supply chains and
creating unprecedented transport-related challenges [Paché
2022]. This section discusses the impact of the conflict in
Ukraine on freight transport and logistics while emphasising the
implications for the Mediterranean region.
The current
conflict between Russia and Ukraine has the potential to
significantly impact logistics and freight transport in
Mediterranean countries. Russia and Ukraine are key players in
land and maritime international logistics and the war is
disrupting international routes that guaranteed the transport of
goods, particularly the route linking Europe and Asia. In
addition, trade sanctions against Russia have fuelled tensions
between Russia and Western countries, including some
Mediterranean countries such as Italy, Spain and Greece. Such
restrictions or trade barriers are having a negative impact on
international trade of Mediterranean countries, limiting the
movement of goods across borders. This unstable and uncertain
political situation has led to supply chain interruptions in the
Mediterranean area.
Wars and conflicts
have a significant impact on freight transport and logistics,
affecting both the movement of goods within the affected
countries and the flow of goods through regional trade
¶{p. 244}routes [Ruta 2022]. The war in Ukraine
has not only created a humanitarian crisis but has caused
extensive economic impacts with substantial global consequences.
The most immediate effects were the increase in energy prices
and the disruption of grain supplies, which led to global food
inflation.
The Middle East and
North Africa region was affected by both. With the exception of
Lebanon (that was already affected by hyperinflation), all the
countries belonging to the MENA region experienced a substantial
increase in the inflation rate in 2022 [ISPI 2023a].
Although the impact
was felt throughout the region, it is hardly surprising that
low- and middle-income oil-importing countries faced more
significant challenges. Low- and middle-income households are
paying a heavy toll for the rising global energy and food
prices.
Most of the
Ukrainian economy is suffering the consequences of the war as
supply chains are disrupted in several sectors such as food,
textiles and other products, as well as equipment and materials
that support the country’s industrial and agricultural sectors.
The most critical transport infrastructures, such as ports or
railways, have been destroyed as a result of war operations and
are now unusable, especially on Russian territory. This has cut
off Russia from international trade and logistics routes.
On the other hand,
the situation in Ukraine is impacting supply chains far beyond
the Ukrainian area. For example, to escape war zones, logistics
companies have adopted the strategy of bypassing the West, via
Scandinavia, or the East, via China, which increases lead times
and costs while reducing transport capacities. Moreover, since
the beginning of the war, the shortage of drivers in the
European road transport sector has become even more severe due
to the lack of Ukrainian drivers.
The most critical
impacts of war on freight transport and logistics that may have
implications on the Mediterranean countries are described below.
– Damage to
infrastructures: Wars and conflicts can significantly damage
transportation infrastructures, such as roads, railways and
ports. One of the major concerns is the damage to transportation
infrastructures in eastern Ukraine. This can make it difficult
and costly to transport goods (e.g. steel and food products),
resulting in longer transit times and higher
¶{p. 245}transportation costs. Damage to
infrastructure can also result in interruptions in the supply
chain, particularly in areas where there are no alternative
routes available. In turn, this could lead to a slowdown in
import and export operations. According to Railtarget (https://www.railtarget.eu/)
since the beginning of the Russia’s military invasion of
Ukraine, up to 30 per cent of transport infrastructure has been
damaged, the extent ranging from complete destruction to
relatively minor repairs. The damage is estimated at US $ 2.9
billion (see fig. 1).